D5.1 - Prototype sea level planning and scenario visualization tool
|
Work Package: |
Lead Beneficary: |
Publication Date: |
As part of Work Package (WP) 5, “Coastal resilience and operational services demonstrator”, task 5.1.3 “Data-driven modelling and visualization for sea level guidance”, aims to improve decision making for flood risk management in the coastal zone. The primary aim is to improve understanding of how the deep uncertainty over climate change induced sea level rise can impact decision making at the early stages of the process. The deliverable 5.1, “Prototype sea level planning and scenario visualization tool” has explored this problem and delivered a visualisation prototype. During project inception, the team identified that the core problem in making informed decisions with Sea Level Rise (SLR) was that the large variation in potential future scenarios was not considered due to the complexity of the processes and calculations required to translate each physical scenario into societal impacts; it did not get through to the economic decisions. The challenge therefore was to provide a full picture of the scientific predictions and associated uncertainty within the economic decision making framework.
During the initial scoping stage of this task, a series of workshops were held between Arup, National Oceanography Centre (NOC), University of Cambridge (UCAM) and CADA Consulting (CADA). In the workshops, the problem was broken down into distinct phases and a workflow was produced to deliver the modelling and visualisation prototype, with actions assigned to Arup, UCAM and CADA. The basic premise of the proposed prototype was to visualise the economic damage resulting from a large set of SLR flood risk scenarios. This required a correspondingly large set of simulations to generate the flood risk data and, potentially, a prohibitive amount of computational expense to estimate the associated economic losses. With the aim of providing a full representation of the scientific uncertainty in the predicted damage, the aim was to reduce the detail in the engineering calculations, which translate the environmental conditions into building level flood impacts, and also the economic calculations that turn flood impacts into damage estimates. This was the alternative to reducing the number of SLR scenarios to be visualised. During this scoping stage, a concept User Interface (UI) was also developed.
The modelling process can be summarised in 3 steps:
1) Specifying nearshore hydrodynamic conditions (still water level, storm surge profile, wave conditions).
2) Calculating the pathway of water onto the land through overflow and wave overtopping of high ground or defences.
3) Determining how the flood water spreads on land.
This was a significant undertaking and a core element of the task. UCAM developed an approach to bring together all elements in a streamlined model workflow. The aim of the approach is for this workflow to be replicable in alternative locations. However, only the case study location has been modelled within the scope of this project.
Alongside the development of the modelling approach, a visualisation prototype was designed and built to receive, process and visualise the modelling outputs. The modelling method results in a very complex set of data focussed on a wide range of “scenarios”. The scenarios are created by three primary sources of uncertainty:
- Emissions scenario (e.g. RCP4.5)
- Model uncertainty for sea level rise predictions within a given emissions scenario (e.g. 50th percentile)
- The multiple wave possibilities combined with the storm and tide extreme still water level combination
The final dimension is the geographical distribution of the flooding; where does the flooding occur and what localised damage is it causing? The spatial calculation grid was simplified but still contained 1000 hexagonal regions to cover the flood extent within Hull.
Altogether, this results in thousands of potential scenarios across 80 years and a thousand geographical points, all requiring an economic damage calculation. The sheer volume of data creates a challenge; how can the user understand the data and how can it be used to inform decisions on the impact of sea level rise? This issue has been resolved through the creation of a visualisation prototype which is a web-based interface to the data, allowing the user to easily select a scenario and, importantly, rapidly change the scenario and compare to other scenarios. In this way the user can immerse themselves in the data and get a feel for how decisions on the originating uncertainty levels (items 1 to 3 above) alter the overall flooding in the region, its distribution and the resulting economic impact.
It was important to achieve sufficiently fast functionality of the visualisation prototype as significant delays between scenario changes would quickly lose the interest of the user and limit the potential for interactive data exploration. To achieve this, the calculations were pre-processed before uploading a static data set to the visualisation prototype. This allowed the incorporation of two different ways to view the data. A single scenario view where the impacts of the chosen scenario inputs can be examined with maps, graphs and metrics. Then a two scenario option where different inputs can be compared alongside each other to understand how certain changes in the physical inputs manifest in the impacts.
Initial stakeholder feedback from the Environment Agency on the visualisation protype was positive and included acknowledging:
- the value in this approach as it explains uncertainty and helps people to understand their own appetite for risk.
- This is a good means of visualising sea level change since people often struggle to understand this in a meaningful way.
- It is useful to see how a change in one small parameter can affect a whole city
- Different stakeholders will want the information at different scales
The future development of this modelling approach and visualisation prototype may consider the following:
- The balance of modelling accuracy with speed of processing according to the location and user needs
- The incorporation of quick defence raising assessments
- Enhanced economic calculations (more detail and or wider economic metrics), again balancing the needs for more information with speed of processing
- Different methods of visualisation, such as 3D, depending on the stakeholder and user needs
- Robustness and testing of the calculations in readiness for commercialisation
This task has proven that the prototype sea level planning and scenario visualization tool is a viable prospective means of communicating the high degree of uncertainty that is inherent in current projections of sea level extremes Future commercialisation depends on follow-on funding to implement the recommended development work. The task consortium plans to continue engagement with existing stakeholders to explore use cases and funding opportunities to refine the prototype in respect of the Humber case study area. At the same time, the task consortium is keen to identify other potential beneficiaries and funding bodies (port operators, coastal communities, insurers, planning authorities etc), who might support the enhancement of the prototype to a commercial standard in other geographical areas.
D5.2 - Mediterranean sea-level reconstruction spanning 1950-2017
|
Work Package: |
Lead Beneficary: |
Publication Date: |
Sea-level change is geographically non-uniform, with regional departures that can reach several times the global average rate of change. Characterizing this spatial variability and understanding its causes is crucial to the design of adaptation strategies for sea-level rise. This, as it turns out, is no easy feat, primarily due to the sparseness of the observational sea-level record in time and space. Long tide gauge records are restricted to a few locations along the coast. Satellite altimetry offers a better spatial coverage but only since 1992. In the Mediterranean Sea, the tide gauge network is heavily biased towards the European shorelines, with only one record with at least 35 years of data on the African coasts. Past studies have attempted to address the difficulties related to this data sparseness in the Mediterranean Sea by combining the available tide gauge records with satellite altimetry observations.
D5.3 - CMEMS downscaled circulation operational forecast system
|
Work Package: |
Lead Beneficary: |
Publication Date: |
This document explains in detail the set-up and implementation of two numerical high-resolution models for the test cases of Taranto and Barcelona, as expected in the EuroSea workplan. Both models are state of the art and have been carefully validated. The operating services resulting will be in the core of OSPAC product, the main deliverable of WP5.2.
The third pilot involved in the project, Alexandría, does not have models ready, since this port, quite unexpectedly, failed to obtain the internally required permits to work in the project. Nevertheless, this is not a concerning delay, since all methodologies are developed, and we are already working on the modelling work for the substitute port designated (Buenaventura, in Colombia). At this moment, locations in Colombia or Madagascar are being studied. Contacts with local authorities are established and a final decision will be made before the end of 2021.
Deliverable Report https://doi.org/10.3289/eurosea_d5.3D5.4 - CMEMS downscaled wave operational forecast system
|
Work Package: |
Lead Beneficary: |
Publication Date: |
This document explains in detail the set-up and implementation of two numerical high-resolution wave models for the Taranto and Barcelona test cases, as expected in the EuroSea work plan. Both models are state-of-the-art and have been carefully validated. The operating services resulting will be in the core of the OSPAC product, the main deliverable of WP5.2.
D5.5 - Final version of the software running operationally for the demonstration
|
Work Package: |
Lead Beneficary: |
Publication Date: |
This report presents the features and the manual for the OSPAC service (Oceanographic Services for Ports and Cities), within the framework of the EuroSea project (funded by the European Union’s Horizon 2020 program, Grant Agreement 862626). OSPAC encloses a one-stop shop of met-ocean indicators and tools for the management and decision support at harbours and coastal cities. This deliverable presents its already implemented applications: (i) real time monitoring; (ii) met-ocean forecasts; (iii) warning system, (iv) floating debris; joint with the User and Administrator manuals for OSPAC.
OSPAC will be implemented at three pilot sites: (i) Barcelona (Spain), (ii) Taranto (Italy) and (iii) Buenaventura (Colombia). At present stage, the Barcelona pilot-site has been successfully implemented in OSPAC and there is a growing user community (more than 30 registered users).
The OSPAC service is already available for Desktop and mobile. Access can be requested through the following website[1].
D5.6 - Documentation associated to the capacity building
|
Work Package: |
Lead Beneficary: |
Publication Date: |
WP5’s Coastal Resilience and Operational Services demonstrator aimed to deliver capacity-building work in a developing country (Colombia) to enable local stakeholders to install a state-of-the-art sea level monitoring system independently. In practice, the WP5 team met this objective and has additionally delivered capacity-building work in tide gauge installation in 2 other countries (Spain and Italy), in order to support the longevity of the EuroSea tide gauge systems. As planned, training material was delivered in relation to the maintenance of these systems in all 3 locations. All installation procedures were fully-documented to support the tide gauge operators in case the systems are to be relocated, refurbished or decommissioned at a future data (for example, in the event of port redevelopment works).
Training in the use of quality control software and the OSPAC (Operational Services at the Service of Ports and Cities) tool is planned (but pending) and this deliverable will be updated once that work is complete.
Deliverable Report https://doi.org/10.3289/eurosea_d5.6D5.7 - Automated tide gauge data quality control software and report
|
Work Package: |
Lead Beneficary: |
Publication Date: |
The WP5 Coastal Resilience and Operational Services demonstrator aims to design and deploy innovative sea level monitoring systems, integrating their observations with downscaled model forecasts into an alert-based monitoring and forecasting tool (OSPAC) that is design for use by ports and local authorities. As part of this data integration process, sea level observations must be quality-controlled in near real-time, to minimise the risk of false alarms. This has historically been achieved using an established open-source software package (SELENE). Recent progress using automatic quality control (QC) in delayed mode has led to the development of additional functionality that could enhance the SELENE software. At the same time, the delivery of new sea level time series from Global Navigation Satellite Systems (GNSS), provides an additional means of data validation. WP5 aims to enhance the SELENE software by incorporating these enhancements and new data feeds, thereby improving the quality of the OSPAC tool.
D5.8 - Mediterranean trend and acceleration sea-level esti-mates (reduced uncertainty, recalculation toolbox)
|
Work Package: |
Lead Beneficary: |
Publication Date: |
Past sea-level changes in the Mediterranean Sea are highly non-uniform and can deviatesignificantly from both the global average sea-level rise and changes in the nearby Atlantic. Understanding thecauses of this spatial non-uniformity is crucial to the success of coastal adaptation strategies. This, however,remains a challenge owing to the lack of long sea-level records in the Mediterranean. Previous studies haveaddressed this challenge by reconstructing past sea levels through objective analysis of sea-level observations.Such reconstructions have enabled significant progress toward quantifying sea-level changes, however, theyhave difficulty capturing long-term changes and provide little insight into the causes of the changes.
D5.9 - Operational monitoring systems available at the three sites
|
Work Package: |
Lead Beneficary: |
Publication Date: |
Tide gauges can capture sea level variability on multiple timescales, from high frequency events like waves, tides and tsunamis, to seasonal and interannual changes and the longer-term trends associated with Climate Change. However, financial constraints dictate that they are often maintained to lower standards than the stringent accuracy requirements demanded by the IOC-UNESCO’s Global Sea Level Observing System (GLOSS) for monitoring sea level rise. In addition, a sparsity of Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS) receivers at the coast means that there are large uncertainties in rates of land motion at tide gauges, which also hampers the estimation of long-term sea level trends.
D5.10 - Final report describing the demonstration and the user feedback at European sites
|
Work Package: |
Lead Beneficary: |
Publication Date: |
The development and implementation of the OSPAC (Oceanographic Services for Ports and Cities) demonstrator in EuroSea Task 5.2 exemplifies the commitment to European innovation and integration of ocean observations and forecasts, facilitating a seamless connection between scientific advancements and the practical needs of end-users. The task combines the deployment of novel measurement equipment, advanced high-resolution coastal forecasts, and the design of tailored downstream services to address the specific requirements of port managers and urban planners, fostering efficient and informed decision-making in both maritime and city planning domains.
The demonstration of OSPAC in three pilot sites underscores its adaptability and effectiveness in diverse coastal settings, providing a tangible example of how EuroSea is bridging the gap between scientific research and the real-world applications essential for advancing the concept of “smart cities” and promoting sustainable practices in port management. The report describes the OSPAC demonstrator characteristics already operational for Barcelona and Taranto pilot sites and the positive feedback, as well as recommendations for future improvements, from end-users at Barcelona and Taranto ports and city councils, during the last 6 months of the project.
This collaborative effort showcases the EuroSea role in connecting scientists with end-users, creating a harmonious synergy between cutting-edge research and the practical tools needed to navigate the challenges of our evolving coastal environments.
D5.11 - Scientific model validation report during the demonstration period
|
Work Package: |
Lead Beneficary: |
Publication Date: |
The skills assessment of high-resolution coastal models developed within the OSPAC (Oceanographic Services for Ports and Cities) demonstrator for Barcelona and Taranto pilot sites has shown positive performance during the August-December 2023 demonstration phase. Comparisons with observational data from new sensors and permanent stations, operationally integrated in OSPAC tool during that period, as well as offline validation exercises from earlier data periods, validate the models’ accuracy. The GNSS-IR technique, utilizing both low-cost and high-precision GNSS sensors, demonstrated its potential for providing significant wave height values at the coast.
In Barcelona, the wave model revealed consistent model performance, despite overestimating certain wave height events. Hydrodynamic modulations by underlying currents were identified as a factor requiring further investigation into waves–current interactions. A 3-month multi-parameter intercomparison for two coastal ocean models (with and without waves-currents coupling) around Barcelona harbour showed robust performance in both cases, capturing events like Storm Babet’s sea level rise. Notably, the coupled model did not outperform the non-coupled model, suggesting the need for the extension of model intercomparison in the future to longer periods including diverse oceanic and meteorological conditions and significant extreme events.
In Taranto, the first day of forecasts is validated against the new sea level and significant wave height data provided by EuroSea tide gauge. For sea level, the results are comparable to the findings of the hindcast validation in previous studies. Regarding the significant wave height, the model shows satisfactory agreement with the two new sources of in situ waves information provided by EuroSea tide gauge, despite overestimating one of the wave peaks observed in the period.
The study highlights the effectiveness of a combined observational and modelling approach for comprehensive coastal processes characterization, leveraging the strengths of both systems.
